| Overview of the 2010 Scummies and Mashies Awards
|
|
|
Awards
| || || ||
|-
| Name Should be in Orange || Behind the Scenes Contribution || Vi || "For Distinguished Service in Spambot-Fighting and General WikiAwesomeness"
|-
| Smooth Operator || Excellent Moderation || Flameaxe || NY 118 - BBM's Large Normal Mafia
|-
| Coffee on the Monitor || Funniest Poster || hitogoroshi || Open 189~Trouble at Warren State Mental Hospital
|-
| Hannibal Lecter || Best Performance by a Third Party || lewarcher82 as Bulletproof Neighbor Serial Killer || Mafia 119: Murder at Hotel Death
|-
| Paperback Writer || Best Flavor Text || SaintKerrigan || Descent into Chaos
|-
| Don Corleone || Most Cunning Manipulator || Sotty7 || Mini 942: Gonzo Mafia
|-
| Paragon of Mafia Hunters || Best Scum Catcher || Glork || Square Enix Mafia I: Diabolus Eres
|-
| Oscar || Best Performance: Scum Group || Chronopie, Debonair Danny DiPietro, DrippingGoofball, Gammagooey, and RedCoyote || Pledge of Allegiance
|-
| Oscar || Best Performance: Pro-Town Team || Benmage, BloodCovenent, Cobalt, chamber, DeathNote, dramonic, DrippingGoofball, Faraday, farside22, Fishythefish, Seacore, SerialClergyman, TonyMontana, Vaya, Vi || Pick Your Power
|-
|| Player's Choice || Most Enjoyable Game || || The Lord of the Rings Mafia
|-
| The Golden Fedora || Lifetime Achievement || MeMe || Both of the Mini queues... since 2003
|}