You are viewing the MafiaScum.net Wiki. To play the game, visit the forum.
Team Mafia (2012): Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
m (→Reception) |
||
(15 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The 2nd [[Team Mafia]] event kicked off in May 2012 with 16 teams. 3 out of 5 games were won by the [[Town]] side. The Captains were announced as the winners on July 2nd, 2012. The runner-up team, The Kliq II, also won all 4 of their games and lost by just 8 points. {{TOCright}} | The 2nd [[Team Mafia]] event kicked off in May 2012 with 16 teams battling it out. This was the first [[Team Mafia]] event to feature more games than players per team. 3 out of 5 games were won by the [[Town]] side. The Captains were announced as the winners on July 2nd, 2012. The runner-up team, The Kliq II, also won all 4 of their games and lost by just 8 points. {{TOCright}} | ||
[https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=21696 Pre-Game Discussion Thread] | [https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=21696 Pre-Game Discussion Thread] | ||
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
==Scoring == | ==Scoring == | ||
This second iteration of [[Team Mafia]] featured changes to the scoring that were intended to avoid the large tie that had resulted the previous year. Still, teams earned points by winning games. It was valuable to "win big." Points earned for each win were modified by the number of surviving players for the winning side relative to other wins for the same side. | This second iteration of [[Team Mafia]] featured changes to the scoring that were intended to avoid the large tie that had resulted the previous year. Still, teams earned points by winning games. It was valuable to "win big." Points earned for each win were modified by the number of surviving players for the winning side relative to other wins for the same side. | ||
Penalty points could be issued for offenses ranging from the Moderator team needing to force replace a player of that team, violations of event rules, disruptive behavior, or causing a modkill. | |||
=== Tie Break === | === Tie Break === | ||
1. Correct wagon behavior on D1 in games where their slot was town. Having been eliminated D1 counts as incorrect. If the D1 eliminated person was mafia, in the final vote count, voting for them is "correct" and not voting for them is "incorrect." If the D1 eliminated person was town, in the final vote count, voting for them is "incorrect" and not voting for them is "correct." (Skip this method if at least one team tied for first were mafia in all 4 games.) | 1. Correct wagon behavior on D1 in games where their slot was town. Having been eliminated D1 counts as incorrect. If the D1 eliminated person was mafia, in the final vote count, voting for them is "correct" and not voting for them is "incorrect." If the D1 eliminated person was town, in the final vote count, voting for them is "incorrect" and not voting for them is "correct." (Skip this method if at least one team tied for first were mafia in all 4 games.) | ||
2. Compare head-to-head matches among tied teams. In other words, any time two teams were on different sides in the same game, whoever was victorious there will break the tie. (Skip this method if results are conflicting.) | 2. Compare head-to-head matches among tied teams. In other words, any time two teams were on different sides in the same game, whoever was victorious there will break the tie. (Skip this method if results are conflicting.) | ||
3. Decision by the Head Mod and Moderators about which team best led their side to victory as well as displayed teamwork in their Team QT. | 3. Decision by the Head Mod and Moderators about which team best led their side to victory as well as displayed teamwork in their Team QT. | ||
=== Scoring Equations === | === Scoring Equations === | ||
For each town victory a team had (results rounded to nearest whole number): | '''For each town victory a team had''' (results rounded to nearest whole number): | ||
[(Number of Surviving Town Members + 25) / (Average Number of Surviving Town Members Across all town wins + 25)]*100 | [(Number of Surviving Town Members + 25) / (Average Number of Surviving Town Members Across all town wins + 25)]*100 | ||
For each scum victory your team had: | |||
'''For each scum victory your team had:''' | |||
[(Number of Surviving Mafia Members * 2 + 25)/(Average number of surviving mafia members across all scum wins * 2 + 25 )]*100 | [(Number of Surviving Mafia Members * 2 + 25)/(Average number of surviving mafia members across all scum wins * 2 + 25 )]*100 | ||
Note: For a White Flag mafia victory, subtract 0.5 from number of surviving mafia members on both sides of the division sign. | Note: For a White Flag mafia victory, subtract 0.5 from number of surviving mafia members on both sides of the division sign. | ||
Equation for Tiebreaker 1: | |||
'''Equation for Tiebreaker 1:''' | |||
Among tied teams: [{(Number of D1 eliminations on a correct elimination as town * 3) - (Number of times that your team was incorrect about a D1 elimination as town)}/(Number of Games Your team was town)] | Among tied teams: [{(Number of D1 eliminations on a correct elimination as town * 3) - (Number of times that your team was incorrect about a D1 elimination as town)}/(Number of Games Your team was town)] | ||
Line 215: | Line 224: | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Captain Ajax}}<br><s>{{U|Captain Corporal}}</s> | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Captain Ajax}}<br><s>{{U|Captain Corporal}}</s> | ||
| '''4-0''' | | '''4-0''' | ||
| '''412''' | | '''412.0''' | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''2''' | | '''2''' | ||
Line 221: | Line 230: | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Zachrulez}} | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Zachrulez}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|JasonT1981}} | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|JasonT1981}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Sotty7}} | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Sotty7}} <s>{{U|Gman}}</s> | ||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Debonair Danny Dipietro}} | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Debonair Danny Dipietro}} | ||
| '''4-0''' | | '''4-0''' | ||
| ''' | | '''403.6''' | ||
|- | |- | ||
| '''3''' | | '''3''' | ||
| Dissonant Consensus | | Dissonant Consensus | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Benmage}} | ||
|308.4 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|MastermindOfSin}} | ||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|T-Bone}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Yosarian2}} | |||
|'''3-1''' | |||
|'''308.4''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''4''' | | '''4''' | ||
| Nuwen and the Skittles | | Nuwen and the Skittles | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|singersigner}} | ||
|300 | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Korts}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|hitogoroshi}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Nuwen}} | |||
|'''3-1''' | |||
|'''300.0''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''5''' | | '''5''' | ||
| No Pressure | | No Pressure | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Cogito Ergo Scum}} | ||
|300 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Glork}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|CrashTextDummie}} | |||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|chamber}} | |||
|'''3-1''' | |||
|'''300.0''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''5''' | | '''5''' | ||
| Single Entendre | | Single Entendre | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Amrun}} | ||
|300 | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Untrod Tripod}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Kublai Khan}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|kuribo}} | |||
|'''3-1''' | |||
|'''300.0''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''7''' | | '''7''' | ||
| Almighty Lumberjacks | | Almighty Lumberjacks | ||
| | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|299.2 | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|DeltaWave}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Slandaar}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|DeasVail}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|4nxi3ty}} | |||
|'''3-1''' | |||
|'''299.2''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''8''' | | '''8''' | ||
| The Parallax Consortium | | The Parallax Consortium | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Johhog}} | ||
|212.0 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|PeregrineV}} | ||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Zar}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Isa}} | |||
|'''2-2''' | |||
|'''212.0''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''9''' | | '''9''' | ||
| Balls Deep Ballas | | Balls Deep Ballas | ||
| | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Nachomamma8}}<br> <s>{{U|Thestatusquo}}</s> | ||
|195.7 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Porochaz}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Ellibereth}} | |||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Kison}} | |||
|'''2-2''' | |||
|'''195.7''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''10''' | | '''10''' | ||
| Team Beat Alls | | Team Beat Alls | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Regfan}} | ||
|192.4 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Slaxx}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Nicodemus}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Magua}} <s>{{U|Gaoth}}</s> | |||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|'''2-2''' | |||
|'''192.4''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''10''' | | '''10''' | ||
| Team Discovery Channel | | Team Discovery Channel | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Matias}} | ||
|192.4 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|iamausername}} | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Rhinox}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|The Fonz}} | |||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|'''2-2''' | |||
|'''192.4''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''12''' | | '''12''' | ||
| Screaming Death Clan | | Screaming Death Clan | ||
| | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|SocioPath}} | ||
|184.5 | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Fate}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|xRECKONERx}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|SpyreX}} | |||
|'''2-2''' | |||
|'''184.5''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''13''' | | '''13''' | ||
| | | Nonsensical Parma Ham Cupcakes | ||
| | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|107.6 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Haylen}} | ||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Katsuki}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Quilford}} | |||
|bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Parama}} | |||
|'''1-3''' | |||
|'''107.6''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''14''' | | '''14''' | ||
| | | Event Horizon Penis Trolls | ||
| | |bgcolor="98fb98"|{{U|Bub Bidderskins}} | ||
|104.3 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|CoolDog}} | ||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|mykonian}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|theamatuer}} | |||
|bgcolor="darkgrey"| | |||
|'''1-3''' | |||
|'''104.3''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''15''' | | '''15''' | ||
| Three Dicks and a Lady | | Three Dicks and a Lady | ||
| | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Llamarble}} | ||
|0-4 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|GreyICE}} | ||
|0 | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|MagnaofIllusion}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Lady Lambdadelta}} | |||
|'''0-4''' | |||
|'''0.0''' | |||
|- | |- | ||
| '''16''' | | '''16''' | ||
| Team BIFADMVOC | | Team BIFADMVOC | ||
| | |bgcolor="darkgrey"| | ||
|0-4 | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|UberNinja}} | ||
| | |bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|SleepyKrew}} | ||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|BBmolla}} | |||
|bgcolor="ffcccb"|{{U|Chesskid3}} | |||
|'''0-4''' | |||
|'''-10.0''' | |||
|} | |} | ||
Line 308: | Line 385: | ||
== Reception == | == Reception == | ||
There was some critical reception of the scoring system. Zoraster stated that for the future, they may need to return to the "drawing board." Some criticism was results-oriented because the winning team had a high volume of replacements. Additionally, there was a complaint from a mafia team member in the Scummies game that their weakest team member in-game was essentially "carried to victory" in the event as a whole. On the other hand, the Head Mod commented about the Captains that "they actually played as a team well once those replacements went through." | |||
Game balance and the challenges of producing theme games for the event were also discussed post-game. The Head Mod reflected that the next iteration would likely have more basic games. | |||
[[Category:Team Mafia]] | [[Category:Team Mafia]] |
Latest revision as of 11:13, 2 March 2024
The 2nd Team Mafia event kicked off in May 2012 with 16 teams battling it out. This was the first Team Mafia event to feature more games than players per team. 3 out of 5 games were won by the Town side. The Captains were announced as the winners on July 2nd, 2012. The runner-up team, The Kliq II, also won all 4 of their games and lost by just 8 points.
Format
The event was played by 16 4-player teams across 5 different games. Team members were public knowledge, though unrevealed alt accounts could be used. Teams received a designated QuickTopic for all team communication during the event that they could continue to participate in post-death. Each team submitted a preference list for which games their team would participate in and these preferences were handled through a snake draft. Role PMs for the team were then received prior to team members deciding which game they would participate in. Teams were responsible for finding their own replacements, and were allowed to replace dead players. It was also within the rules to have a dead player in one game replace into another game.
Zoraster remained as Head Mod of the event. He was joined by a new team of moderators and setup designers including: Equinox, hasdgfas, Vi, Faraday, and Mina.
Scoring
This second iteration of Team Mafia featured changes to the scoring that were intended to avoid the large tie that had resulted the previous year. Still, teams earned points by winning games. It was valuable to "win big." Points earned for each win were modified by the number of surviving players for the winning side relative to other wins for the same side.
Penalty points could be issued for offenses ranging from the Moderator team needing to force replace a player of that team, violations of event rules, disruptive behavior, or causing a modkill.
Tie Break
1. Correct wagon behavior on D1 in games where their slot was town. Having been eliminated D1 counts as incorrect. If the D1 eliminated person was mafia, in the final vote count, voting for them is "correct" and not voting for them is "incorrect." If the D1 eliminated person was town, in the final vote count, voting for them is "incorrect" and not voting for them is "correct." (Skip this method if at least one team tied for first were mafia in all 4 games.)
2. Compare head-to-head matches among tied teams. In other words, any time two teams were on different sides in the same game, whoever was victorious there will break the tie. (Skip this method if results are conflicting.)
3. Decision by the Head Mod and Moderators about which team best led their side to victory as well as displayed teamwork in their Team QT.
Scoring Equations
For each town victory a team had (results rounded to nearest whole number):
[(Number of Surviving Town Members + 25) / (Average Number of Surviving Town Members Across all town wins + 25)]*100
For each scum victory your team had:
[(Number of Surviving Mafia Members * 2 + 25)/(Average number of surviving mafia members across all scum wins * 2 + 25 )]*100
Note: For a White Flag mafia victory, subtract 0.5 from number of surviving mafia members on both sides of the division sign.
Equation for Tiebreaker 1:
Among tied teams: [{(Number of D1 eliminations on a correct elimination as town * 3) - (Number of times that your team was incorrect about a D1 elimination as town)}/(Number of Games Your team was town)]
Teams
Games
Name of Game | Type | Moderator | Winner |
---|---|---|---|
TM2012: White Flag Mafia | Open - White Flag | Equinox | Town |
TM2012: Closed Normal | Closed - Normal | hasdgfas | Mafia |
TM2012: Almost Normal | Closed | zoraster | Town |
TM2012: Scummies 2012.5 | Closed - Theme | Lost Butterfly | Mafia |
TM2012: Mafia in the Back Room | Closed - Theme | Vi | Town |
Results
Rank | Team Name | White Flag | Closed Normal | Almost Normal | Scummies | Back Room | W/L | Score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | The Captains | Captain Falcon |
Captain Leela |
Captain Ajax | Captain Ajax |
4-0 | 412.0 | |
2 | The Kliq II | Zachrulez | JasonT1981 | Sotty7 |
Debonair Danny Dipietro | 4-0 | 403.6 | |
3 | Dissonant Consensus | Benmage | MastermindOfSin | T-Bone | Yosarian2 | 3-1 | 308.4 | |
4 | Nuwen and the Skittles | singersigner | Korts | hitogoroshi | Nuwen | 3-1 | 300.0 | |
5 | No Pressure | Cogito Ergo Scum | Glork | CrashTextDummie | chamber | 3-1 | 300.0 | |
5 | Single Entendre | Amrun | Untrod Tripod | Kublai Khan | kuribo | 3-1 | 300.0 | |
7 | Almighty Lumberjacks | DeltaWave | Slandaar | DeasVail | 4nxi3ty | 3-1 | 299.2 | |
8 | The Parallax Consortium | Johhog | PeregrineV | Zar | Isa | 2-2 | 212.0 | |
9 | Balls Deep Ballas | Nachomamma8 |
Porochaz | Ellibereth | Kison | 2-2 | 195.7 | |
10 | Team Beat Alls | Regfan | Slaxx | Nicodemus | Magua |
2-2 | 192.4 | |
10 | Team Discovery Channel | Matias | iamausername | Rhinox | The Fonz | 2-2 | 192.4 | |
12 | Screaming Death Clan | SocioPath | Fate | xRECKONERx | SpyreX | 2-2 | 184.5 | |
13 | Nonsensical Parma Ham Cupcakes | Haylen | Katsuki | Quilford | Parama | 1-3 | 107.6 | |
14 | Event Horizon Penis Trolls | Bub Bidderskins | CoolDog | mykonian | theamatuer | 1-3 | 104.3 | |
15 | Three Dicks and a Lady | Llamarble | GreyICE | MagnaofIllusion | Lady Lambdadelta | 0-4 | 0.0 | |
16 | Team BIFADMVOC | UberNinja | SleepyKrew | BBmolla | Chesskid3 | 0-4 | -10.0 |
Awards
- Best in-game team: Town of White Flag: Amrun, Benmage, Bub Bidderskins, Captain Falcon, Cogito Ergo Scum, Johhog, Matias, Regfan, singersigner, Zachrulez
- Best individual performance, town: Cogito Ergo Scum
- Best individual performance, scum: JasonT1981
Reception
There was some critical reception of the scoring system. Zoraster stated that for the future, they may need to return to the "drawing board." Some criticism was results-oriented because the winning team had a high volume of replacements. Additionally, there was a complaint from a mafia team member in the Scummies game that their weakest team member in-game was essentially "carried to victory" in the event as a whole. On the other hand, the Head Mod commented about the Captains that "they actually played as a team well once those replacements went through."
Game balance and the challenges of producing theme games for the event were also discussed post-game. The Head Mod reflected that the next iteration would likely have more basic games.