You are viewing the MafiaScum.net Wiki. To play the game, visit the forum.

Prisoner's Gambit: Difference between revisions

From MafiaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(cat:gambits (arguably))
(term replacement)
 
(3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Alluding to the famous game theory situation known as the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_Dilemma Prisoner's dilemma], in a [[Mafia game]] this is typically an [[Endgame]] scenario where a single powerless [[Townie]] is left with a [[Serial Killer]] and a single [[Mafia]]; each player's normal play in this case will end up disastrous. For example:
The '''Prisoner's Gambit''' is a scum gambit that tends to crop up in [[Dilemma]] scenarios, named after the Prisoner's Dilemma in game theory.
* If the [[ProTown]] player helps [[Lynch]] one of the [[Scum]], then the other one will kill them that [[Night]]. Therefore their only real option is to vote for [[No Lynch]] and wait to see what happens at night.
* If both [[Scum]] vote to lynch the [[Townie]], then they are each left with only one [[Night Choice]], killing each other and ending in a [[Draw]]. Therefore, they should either lynch the other [[Scum]], or go for [[No Lynch]].
* Assuming rational play, then, all three players have made it to [[Night]]; but now each [[Scum]] has a choice: kill the [[Townie]], or eliminate their rival?
** If one of them kills the [[Townie]], and the other targets them for death, then they hand victory to their opponent.
** However, if they ''both'' kill the [[Townie]], then the two Scum survive until the next [[Day]], and depending on the [[Game Moderator]], they may both win, or be faced with killing each other anyway.
** Finally, if they each kill the other [[Scum]], then they hand victory directly to the powerless [[Townie]].


The entire situation is predicated on trust and self-interest; thus far, no one has found a foolproof way to assure their own victory when this situation arises.
==When To Use==


[[Category:Gambits]]
When the player is one of two killing anti-town factions remaining (usually some set of [[Mafia]], [[Werewolf]], or [[Serial Killer]]), and the third player is a [[Townie]].
 
==Execution==
 
Suppose a game has one [[Townie]], one [[Mafioso]], and one [[Serial Killer]].  The Townie has no incentive to eliminate anyone, and votes No Elimination.  The Mafioso knows that they have to kill the Serial Killer this Night, and vice versa.
 
At this point, one or both of the scum may gambit by offering to shoot the [[Townie]].  If both scum shoot the [[Townie]], then they may draw - not as good as a win, but better than a loss.  On the other hand, if they both shoot each other, the Townie will win (often unjustifiably given the Town's play if the game got to this point).  What is often left unsaid is that if, say, the Mafioso shoots the Townie and the SK shoots the Mafioso, the SK wins outright.
 
It is mathematically best to always shoot the other scum.  But then again, the other scum knows that too, and they're supposed to be aiming at you, so it's probably better to persuade them to shoot the Townie... regardless of what you choose to do in the end.
 
[[Category:Gambits]][[Category:Endgame Gambits]]

Latest revision as of 04:18, 3 July 2020

The Prisoner's Gambit is a scum gambit that tends to crop up in Dilemma scenarios, named after the Prisoner's Dilemma in game theory.

When To Use

When the player is one of two killing anti-town factions remaining (usually some set of Mafia, Werewolf, or Serial Killer), and the third player is a Townie.

Execution

Suppose a game has one Townie, one Mafioso, and one Serial Killer. The Townie has no incentive to eliminate anyone, and votes No Elimination. The Mafioso knows that they have to kill the Serial Killer this Night, and vice versa.

At this point, one or both of the scum may gambit by offering to shoot the Townie. If both scum shoot the Townie, then they may draw - not as good as a win, but better than a loss. On the other hand, if they both shoot each other, the Townie will win (often unjustifiably given the Town's play if the game got to this point). What is often left unsaid is that if, say, the Mafioso shoots the Townie and the SK shoots the Mafioso, the SK wins outright.

It is mathematically best to always shoot the other scum. But then again, the other scum knows that too, and they're supposed to be aiming at you, so it's probably better to persuade them to shoot the Townie... regardless of what you choose to do in the end.

Retrieved from "http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Prisoner%27s_Gambit&oldid=139151"