Survivor PD

Survivor PD [1] Year: 2020 Best Social Game Award ORG/LSG Format: MafiaScum-Hosted Survivor Type: Anonymous Players: 21 Moderator(s): Haschel Cedricson, CreativeMod1, DeasVail LSG List Mod: PrivateI Winner(s): Skelda Runner-Up(s): Aronis Standard classification.

Survivor PD is a Large Social Game which took place between June 27, 2020 and August 16, 2029 . It was moderated by Haschel Cedricson, CreativeMod1 and DeasVail. Skelda (portraying Hercule Poirot) defeated Aronis (portraying Lucifer Morningstar) in a 5-4 vote.

The game was classified as Standard and can be found at this link: https://www.mafiascum.net/social-games/game-20190906/index.php

Players

Player	Original Tribe	First Swap Tribe	Second Swap Tribe	Merged Tribe	Finish
Ace Ventura Chemist1422	27th Precinct				1st Voted Out 21st Place
Officer Jenny NotAJumbleofNumbers	99th Precinct				2nd Voted Out 20th Place
Hannah Wells rahladahla	27th Precinct				3rd Voted Out 19th Place
Chan Ka-kui Panzerjager	12th Precinct	Special Victims Unit			4th Voted Out 18th Place
Kate Macer tris	12th Precinct	Special Victims Unit			5th Voted Out 17th Place
Paul Blart D3f3nd3r	27th Precinct	Special Victims Unit			6th Voted Out 16th Place
Chase Save The Dragons	12th Precinct	Special Victims Unit			7th Voted Out 15th Place
Quentin Lance 0verki11	99th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Narcotics Unit		8th Voted Out 14th Place
Cheddar DrumBeats	99th Precinct	Special Victims Unit	Narcotics Unit		9th Voted Out 13th Place
Nick Wilde CaptainMeme	12th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Strike Team		10th Voted Out 12th Place
Detective Pikachu kdowns	12th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Narcotics Unit	Mafiascum's Finest	11th Voted Out 11th Place 1st Juror
Scruff McGruff Shrek	27th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Narcotics Unit	Mafiascum's Finest	12th Voted Out 10th Place 2nd Juror
Grouch Cop xofelf	99th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Narcotics Unit	Mafiascum's Finest	13th Voted Out 9th Place 3rd Juror
Jake Peralta Pine	27th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Strike Team	Mafiascum's Finest	14th Voted Out 8th Place 4th Juror
Lennie Briscoe het	27th Precinct	Special Victims Unit	Strike Team	Mafiascum's Finest	15th Voted Out 7th Place 5th Juror
Judy Hopps Espeonage	99th Precinct	Special Victims Unit	Strike Team	Mafiascum's Finest	16th Voted Out 6th Place 6th Juror
Penelope Garcia Mist7676	12th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Strike Team	Mafiascum's Finest	17th Voted Out 5th Place 7th Juror
Leon Kennedy keyenpeydee	27th Precinct	Special Victims Unit	Narcotics Unit	Mafiascum's Finest	18th Voted Out 4th Place 8th Juror
Rust Cohle OhGodMyLife	12th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Narcotics Unit	Mafiascum's Finest	19th Voted Out 3rd Place 9th Juror
Lucifer Morningstar Aronis	99th Precinct	Behavioral Analysis Unit	Strike Team	Mafiascum's Finest	Runner-up
Hercule Poirot Skelda	99th Precinct	Special Victims Unit	Strike Team	Mafiascum's Finest	Sole Survivor

Voting History

PD Premerge Voting History
	Original Tribes			First Swap Tribes				Second Swap Tribes
Episode #:	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10
Eliminated:	Ace Ventura	Officer Jenny	Hannah Wells	Chan Ka-kui	Kate Macer	Paul Blart	Chase	Quentin Lance	Cheddar	Nick Wilde
Votes:	6-1	5-2	5-1	8-1	1-7*	6-1	4-2	5-1-1	4-2	5-1-1*
Hercule Poirot		Officer Jenny		Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart	Paul Blart	Chase			Nick Wilde
Lucifer Morningstar		Officer Jenny								Nick Wilde
Rust Cohle								Quentin Lance	Cheddar
Leon Kennedy	Ace Ventura		Hannah Wells	Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart	Paul Blart	Chase	Quentin Lance	Cheddar
Penelope Garcia										Judy Hopps
Judy Hopps		Quentin Lance		Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart	Paul Blart	Chase			Nick Wilde
Lennie Briscoe	Ace Ventura		Hannah Wells	Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart	Paul Blart	Chase			Nick Wilde
Jake Peralta	Ace Ventura		Hannah Wells							Nick Wilde
Grouch Cop		Officer Jenny						Quentin Lance	Detective Pikachu
Scruff McGruff	Ace Ventura		Hannah Wells					Quentin Lance	Cheddar
Detective Pikachu								Detective Pikachu	Cheddar
Nick Wilde										Lucifer Morningstar
Cheddar		Officer Jenny		Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart	Paul Blart	Leon Kennedy	Quentin Lance	Detective Pikachu
Quentin Lance		Officer Jenny						Scruff McGruff
Chase				Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart	Paul Blart	Leon Kennedy
Paul Blart	Ace Ventura		Hannah Wells	Kate Macer	Kate Macer	Leon Kennedy
Kate Macer				Chan Ka-kui	Paul Blart
Chan Ka-kui				Chan Ka-kui
Hannah Wells	Ace Ventura		Paul Blart
Officer Jenny		Quentin Lance
Ace Ventura	Hannah Wells

PD Merge Voting History
Episode #:	11	12	13	14	15	16	17	18	19	20
Eliminated:	Detective Pikachu	Scruff McGruff	Grouch Cop	Jake Peralta	Lennie Briscoe	Judy Hopps	Penelope Garcia	Leon Kennedy	Rust Cohle	Lucifer Morningstar	Hercule Poirot
Immune:	Scruff McGruff	Penelope Garcia and Hercule Poirot	Lennie Briscoe	Judy Hopps	Judy Hopps	Lucifer Morningstar	Rust Cohle	Lucifer Morningstar	Lucifer Morningstar
Votes:	3-8*	8-1-1	5-4	7-1	5-2	5-1	4-1	2-1-1	1 vote	4 to win	5 to win
Hercule Poirot	Jake Peralta	Scruff McGruff	Grouch Cop	Jake Peralta	Penelope Garcia	Judy Hopps	Penelope Garcia	Leon Kennedy
Lucifer Morningstar	Jake Peralta	Scruff McGruff	Jake Peralta	Jake Peralta	Lennie Briscoe	Judy Hopps	Penelope Garcia	Rust Cohle	Rust Cohle
Rust Cohle	Jake Peralta	Scruff McGruff	Jake Peralta	Jake Peralta	Lennie Briscoe	Judy Hopps	Penelope Garcia	Leon Kennedy			Hercule Poirot
Leon Kennedy	Detective Pikachu	Rust Cohle	Grouch Cop	Jake Peralta	Lennie Briscoe	Judy Hopps	Penelope Garcia	Hercule Poirot		Lucifer Morningstar
Penelope Garcia	Jake Peralta	Scruff McGruff	Jake Peralta	Jake Peralta	Lennie Briscoe	Judy Hopps	Hercule Poirot				Hercule Poirot
Judy Hopps	Jake Peralta	Scruff McGruff	Grouch Cop	Jake Peralta	Lennie Briscoe	Penelope Garcia					Hercule Poirot
Lennie Briscoe	Detective Pikachu	Scruff McGruff	Grouch Cop	Jake Peralta	Penelope Garcia						Hercule Poirot
Jake Peralta	Detective Pikachu	Scruff McGruff	Grouch Cop	Lucifer Morningstar							Hercule Poirot
Grouch Cop	Jake Peralta	Scruff McGruff	Jake Peralta							Lucifer Morningstar
Scruff McGruff	Jake Peralta	Jake Peralta								Lucifer Morningstar
Detective Pikachu	Jake Peralta									Lucifer Morningstar

Synopsis

When the game began, the players were divided into three tribes: the 12th , 27th, and 99th precincts. When the 27th precinct lost the first challenge, Ace was voted out for being inactive. The following round, when the 99th precinct lost the challenge, despite having one player, Quentin Lance, who was extremely inactive, they decided to vote out Officer Jenny, who had rubbed multiple players the wrong way. In the final round before the swap, the 27th precinct lost again, and despite a push from Jake Peralta to eliminate Paul Blart, Hannah Wells was the third player eliminated.

At final 18, the players swapped tribes into the Special Victims Unit and the Behavioral Analysis Unit. The Special Victims Unit went on to lose four straight challenges, solidifying themselves as one of the worst performing tribes in Mafiascum history. An alliance called LL ‘Cule J between Lennie Briscoe, Leon Kennedy, Hercule Poirot and Judy Hopps formed soon after the swap, and they would go on to control the votes as their tribe continued losing, eliminating Chan Ka-kui, Paul Blart, and Chase in turn. The alliance was shocked, however, when during the second round of swap Paul Blart successfully played an idol on himself, eliminating Kate Macer with a single vote. Meanwhile, on the Behavioral Analysis Unit, Quentin Lance continued to be inactive and thus found himself on the outs, but there were also some whispers of targeting Penelope Garcia in order to prevent the 12th precinct from obtaining control of the tribe. Detective Pikachu attempted to throw a challenge in order to save Chase on the other tribe, but he was unsuccessful.

After four rounds, the tribes swapped again, this time into the Strike Force and the Narcotics Unit. The Narcotics Unit lost twice in a row, first finally eliminating the inactive Quentin Lance and then blindsiding Cheddar with an idol in his pocket, leaving Grouch Cop alone and on the outs. Then, Strike Force lost the challenge and though Jake Peralta, Penelope Garcia, and Nick Wilde attempted to keep the former Behavioral Analysis Unit together in order to vote off Judy Hopps, after hearing that his former tribemates were throwing out his name as a fake vote, Lucifer Morningstar flipped on them and turned the tide against Nick Wilde, who became the final member of the prejury.

At the merge, an alliance called 1227 formed between the former 12th and 27th precincts minus Lennie Briscoe, but after a vehement disagreement between Detective Pikachu and Jake Peralta about whom to target, the alliance dissolved. Penelope Garcia, who previously had been tightly aligned with Jake Peralta, grew fed up with his behavior and decided to rally the votes against him. After a chaotic round in which the vote between Detective Pikachu and Jake Peralta flipped back and forth multiple times, Scruff McGruff announced to the entire game that he was voting against Jake because he believed the votes were already there, unwittingly solidifying the votes against him. Hercule Poirot and Lennie Briscoe, having failed to rally the votes to save Jake, tipped him off that the votes were against him, causing him to play his idol and send Detective Pikachu home. Scruff’s erratic behavior and poor communication this round irritated many players, which caused him to be targeted and eliminated next.

At final 9, the LL ‘Cule J alliance pulled in Jake, who was being targeted by the rest of the game, in order to seize control and blindside Grouch Cop in a 5-4 vote. Their control over the game did not last long, however, because the following round, Judy Hopps and Leon Kennedy flipped on the alliance to work with the newly formed group of Penelope Garcia, Rust Cohle and Lucifer Morningstar to eliminate Jake Peralta. Then, at final 7, Lennie Briscoe followed Jake out the door, despite his close ally Hercule Poirot’s efforts to save him, including a failed attempt to flip the vote on to another ally, Leon Kennedy. Partially as a result of this attempt, which had been goaded by Rust Cohle in order to divide Leon and Poirot, a final three alliance between Rust, Lucifer, and Leon formed.

At final 6 and final 5, Judy Hopps and Penelope Garcia were voted out for being challenge and Jury threats. Then, at final 4, the players learned that the game would be a F2. Because of this, Rust and Poirot both knew that if the other went home, they would be relying on winning the Final Immunity Challenge in order to make it to the end due to the fact that both Leon and Lucifer were not perceived as Jury threats. They therefore decided to both secretly vote for Leon, the only option since Lucifer was Immune. Initially both Leon and Lucifer were planning to vote together for Poirot, but after hours of pleading, Poirot was able to convince Leon to lie to Lucifer about his vote in order to (in Leon’s mind) tie the vote between Rust and Poirot and force a firemaking challenge. Lucifer wanted to vote for Rust because he viewed him as a bigger threat to win the F3 challenge than Poirot and because Rust had been intentionally driving him away but Lucifer did not want to tie the vote and was therefore unwilling to vote for Rust unless Leon was also doing so. Leon ultimately decided to lie to Lucifer that he was voting for Rust, causing Lucifer to change his vote from Poirot to Rust and sending himself home 2-1-1.

After Leon’s elimination, Lucifer was left feeling betrayed and hurt by both Rust and Poirot and not particularly confident about his Jury chances against either of them. He then narrowly won Immunity and decided to eliminate Rust because he felt that it would be easier to contrast his game with Poirot’s than with Rust’s due to having been on opposite sides for most of the game. At final tribal council, some Jurors praised Poirot for his social game and strategic influence, while other Jurors criticized his use of emotional manipulation. Lucifer’s more under-the-radar strategy, on the other hand, was both praised and criticized by Jurors. In the end, Hercule Poirot narrowly won the game in a 5-4 decision, receiving votes from his allies Jake Peralta, Lennie Briscoe and Judy Hopps, as well as from Rust Cohle and Penelope Garcia. Lucifer meanwhile received a vote from his ally Grouch Cop and the votes of Detective Pikachu, Scruff McGruff, and Leon Kennedy due to playing a less manipulative game than Poirot.